|back to articles|
Not Too Soft, Not Too Strict:
A Balanced Approach to Parenting
By Don R. MacMannis, Ph.D.
and Debra Manchester, M.S.W.
| There is little less trouble in governing a family than a whole kingdom.
| Stephen and Paula, very caring and involved parents, brought their five-year-old son, Charlie,
in for help with his behavior problems. Charlie had been kicked out of preschool and private kindergarten
programs because of defiant and aggressive behavior. Now his parents were desperate because their “little angel”
had bitten the teacher’s aide.|
Charlie was about as cute as they come, but pranced around the office with the same “air” that had been described at school.
At our first session, his mother handled his breaking of crayons and hanging out the window by saying in a sweet and
tentative voice, “Now Charlie, please don’t do that, OK?” Stephen said absolutely nothing until his son’s behavior began
careening out of control, at which point he barked orders, frightening everybody. Paula would then criticize him for being
too harsh on their little boy.
During the course of family therapy, Stephen and Paula began to understand how experiences with their own parents had left
scars that made it difficult to set limits with their son. Stephen became aware of harsh treatment by his parents, and in a
moving session expressed a lot of anger at his dad for beating him. His fear of this pent-up anger spilling out on Charlie
had rendered him incapable of being firm.
Paula, on the other hand, realized that she was copying her parents’ lackadaisical style by giving Charlie too much freedom.
The youngest of seven children, she had been all but ignored by her parents, who worked long hours and had little time for
the children. Her care had been entrusted to her older brothers and sisters who had neither the skills nor desire to
discipline her. In therapy, Paula grieved about the lack of parenting she received and her unfulfilled desire for nurturing.
Little by little, she became better able to set appropriate limits for Charlie.
Stephen and Paula are not alone. Countless parents are grappling with a child or adolescent who is “acting out” or exhibiting
other problematic behavior which is often simply a cry for a more balanced form of discipline. For Stephen and Paula,
the solution was two-tiered. They needed to provide consistent limits and they needed to learn to work together as a team.
These are two essential goals set by parents who are intent on happy, healthy family-making.
Family researchers have known for years that healthy families create environments that balance large doses of love
and warmth with sufficient firmness and structure. Kids thrive in these settings. Without love and warmth they tend
to feel abandoned and resentful, and without firmness and structure they will often become anxious and/or have behavior
problems. Record numbers of teenagers in the United States are committing more violent crimes at younger ages, using
drugs, dropping out of school, and having little or no hope for their future. Most of these youngsters spent their
youth in home settings that were either too soft or too strict, and are searching for the acceptance they never received
or the boundaries that they were crying out for.
Politicians and pundits ask for a return to “family values,” a phrase repeated by conservatives and liberals alike,
but never really address what this means in everyday terms. From a practical standpoint, they are talking about the
need for responsibility and respect in our youth. In healthy families, when a parent makes a request, their child or
teenager will comply. It’s not always with an instant response or cheery smiles as in TV’s Leave It to Beaver.
No child can be expected to do exactly what mom or dad says the very first time every time they say something.
Children are still children, and it is part of their nature to stretch limits, test, and experiment with the world
around them. However, parents who are loving and in charge know that they can enforce their requests, and when they
“really mean it”, their child will comply.
Families That Are Too Soft
How times have changed; a century ago minding one’ s children didn’t mean obeying them. —Anonymous
Over the past fifty years families of all socioeconomic and ethnic backgrounds have become significantly more
soft or permissive than in the past. In part, this shift is seen as a reaction to the overly stern or authoritarian
parenting today’s adults received, as is reflected in the often-uttered statement “I’ll never treat my kids the way
I was brought up!” Other researchers link today’s increased permissiveness to current economic stresses. Each year,
more and more parents are working outside the home, allowing them less time to spend with their kids. The guilt stemming
from this shortage of family time, and from divorce as well, often prompts parents to be more lenient—an understandable
but unhelpful means of compensating. Although being together as a family is important, the quantity of time devoted to it
is not nearly as crucial as the quality of our interactions and the methods of discipline we use. In most families where kids
are misbehaving, the hierarchy is upside down: the kids wielding more power than their parents.
When asked why they allow their children to wield so much power over them, many parents say that discipline might injure
their child’s self-esteem. In reality, letting children get away with too much can be as damaging to their feelings of
self-worth as being too strict. When kids have too much power, they become anxious about the impulses they cannot control,
and as a result they feel bad about themselves.
Although parents should be in charge, this doesn’t mean that they deserve respect and their children don’t. Respect should
flow in both directions. Children who feel respected and understood for their feelings, in turn, listen to their parents— not
like little robots or bushy-tailed people pleasers, but also not like defiant insurrectionists.
Families That Are Too Strict
With a sweet tongue and kindness, you can drag an elephant by a hair. —Persian proverb
At the other end of the power continuum are families that are too strict. This pattern often stifles a child’s spirit and
leads to resentment and rebellion, as it did with seventeen-year-old Priscilla.
Priscilla, a bright student, had been “busted” in school for possession of marijuana. To be admitted back to classes, the
school dictated that she and her parents had to undergo at least three family therapy sessions. Her parents, initially
startled at the request to be involved in these sessions, soon recognized that they could be helpful agents of change.
In the first meeting we learned that the marijuana incident was only the tip of the iceberg. Pricilla had also recently
run away from home a number of times and was doing poorly in classes despite her high intelligence. Part way through the
second session it was clear that her parents were being far too strict with her. She was expected to baby-sit for her
six-year-old sister every day after school without compensation or even verbal appreciation. Moreover, before the marijuana
bust, she had been grounded from all social activities for a month as punishment for cutting a class to be with friends.
In general, Priscilla’s parents were unaware of the kinds of rules and consequences that make sense for teenagers.
In family therapy, they learned to moderate their limit setting by being more positive, less punitive, and providing
consequences that were more closely tied to Priscilla’s behavior. And the more they respected and listened to their
daughter’s feelings, the less angry, more compliant, and happier she became.
Working as a Team
When there is more than one parenting figure in the home, it is essential that the adults work together as partners,
like co-captains of a team. Directing in a reliable and consistent way, parenting partners must also make some
decisions behind closed doors. Although it is helpful to include input from the children at times, parents need to be in
charge of the timing and appropriateness of their kids’ involvement in the decision-making. This is very different than
allowing the kids to interrupt, get in the middle, or dictate the terms of their own discipline.
Problems can arise if one parent becomes stuck in the role of “ bad guy” while the other takes on the role of “nice guy.”
Like a seesaw, one parent gets progressively more permissive as the other gets too strict. Although attempting to balance
each other, they are actually casting each other as the enemy, blaming their partner for the children’s problems. Before
long, kids begin playing one against the other, and if the parents are unable to work out their differences, conflict
intensifies and they become even more polarized.
Rather than putting blame or fault on the other parent, the best solution is for parents to compromise a bit,
shifting their weight toward the center of the seesaw. The strict parent needs to bring more love and warmth into
their relationship with the children, while the permissive parent must learn to provide structure and set firmer limits.
In addition, both parents need to agree on basic family rules and expectations. When surrounded by a positive family
atmosphere with reasonable, age-appropriate rules and consequences, children naturally learn appropriate behavior and tend
to be happier and healthier.
Don MacMannis, Ph.D. and Debra Manchester, M.S.W. are married and co-direct the Family Therapy Institute of Santa Barbara. Don is a child psychologist and also the music director
and song-writer for Jay Jay the Jet Plane on PBS. He has been interviewed by numerous radio programs,
Time Magazine, Inside Edition, Time for Kids, AOL, and At Home-Live. His latest creative project,
A Pocket of Tunes, is an award-winning CD of songs and activities for children 3-9 years old that
Parenting Magazine called “so inviting and upbeat, kids may not notice it’s teaching them a thing or
two about sharing and kindness as they bop to the beats.” It can be found at APocketofTunes.com.